Home › Articles

Selling a house that needs major repairs

The estimate came back and the math stopped working. Here is why fixing it first is usually the worse of the two options.

Hometide buys houses as-is, for cash, on the seller’s timeline. This article is general information, not legal or tax advice.

Usually it is the roof. Sometimes it is the furnace, or a foundation contractor who says the word “settling” and then a number with five digits in it.

And the math stops working. You would have to fix it to list it. You would have to borrow to fix it. And you would be borrowing against a house you were already trying to get out from under.

What fixing it first actually costs

The repair quote is only the first number. The full cost of getting a house market-ready looks more like this:

The repairs themselves, which on an older house reliably come in above the estimate once something is opened up.
The money to fund them. If you had it sitting there, you would probably not be reading this. Which means borrowing, on a house you are selling.
The months it takes. Contractors on a house nobody lives in are rarely in a hurry, and every one of those months costs you taxes, insurance and utilities.
The commission afterward, calculated on the higher price you just paid to create.
The risk. You are spending certain money today for an uncertain price later.

Sometimes this still comes out ahead. On a house needing cosmetic work in a strong market, it often does. On a house needing a roof, mechanicals and a kitchen, it usually doesn’t — and the person carrying all of the risk is you.

The thing almost nobody accounts for: you are not just paying for repairs, you are financing a renovation on a house you have already decided to leave, and taking the market risk on the far end of it.

The lender problem, which quietly decides everything

This is the part that catches people out, and it is worth understanding before you plan anything.

Most buyers need a mortgage. Most mortgages require the property to meet the lender’s minimum condition standards — a sound roof, working heat, no active leaks, functioning plumbing and electrics, no major structural issues. Government-backed loans are stricter still.

So a house with a failing roof isn’t just less attractive to ordinary buyers. It is frequently unavailable to them, because their lender will not fund it. The buyer pool for a house needing real work is mostly people paying cash, whether you list it or not.

That is the honest reason as-is sales exist, and it is worth knowing before you spend three months and a home equity loan discovering it.

What “we buy it as it is” covers

All of it. Not as a slogan — as the actual scope:

The roof, however far gone.
The furnace, the water heater, the electrical panel, the plumbing.
Foundation and structural work.
Water damage, mould, fire damage.
The kitchen and bathrooms, including the one that has been down to studs since 2019.
Everything still inside the house, including whatever is in the garage.
The yard, the deck, the shed nobody has opened in years.

No inspection you have to pass. No repair list to negotiate. No contractor in your driveway on a Tuesday morning.

One thing that is not covered, and should not be: as-is means you fix nothing. It does not mean you say nothing. Tell a buyer what you know about the house — we are pricing the repairs anyway, and a problem named up front almost never breaks a sale, while a surprise found later reliably does.

Repairs that occasionally are worth making

Being honest about the exceptions: if you are listing rather than selling as-is, a few things genuinely pay for themselves. Cleaning, clearing and basic yard work usually return more than they cost. So does fixing anything actively causing damage — a leak getting worse is a bigger number every month you leave it.

What rarely pays back on a house you are leaving: a new kitchen, a full bathroom renovation, or new windows throughout. Those are renovations done for the next owner’s benefit at your expense.

Curious what the house is worth exactly as it stands, with nothing fixed and nothing cleared out? It costs nothing to find out.

Get a no-obligation offer

How to think about the two numbers

You will end up comparing two figures. Compare them properly:

The as-is number, which is what you receive, minus nothing.
The fixed-up number, minus the repairs, minus the money to fund them, minus the carrying costs for the months it takes, minus the commission, adjusted for the risk that it takes longer or sells for less than hoped.

People compare the as-is offer against the second number before all the subtractions, decide the offer is insulting, and spend a year finding out. Do the subtraction first. Sometimes listing still wins — and if that is what your arithmetic says, list it.